The "Better" Cat Litter Cake

Halloween Recipes

I have a Cat Litter Cake recipe is the best of the best. There are many sites that has this gruesome recipe. I changed just about Yummy Cat Litter Cake!everything in this recipe. This Cat Litter cake is much better than the others (especially if you like brownies - yum!)

It turned out really great! It has that "yuck" appeal and is extremely tasty. We also have seven cats so it was very easy to get the "reality" feeling for this cake. It looked very authentic.

This is an extremely easy recipe. Looks like a lot of work but it's really not.

**This is an original recipe. If you like this Cat Litter Cake recipe enough to post on your website or any forums, please make sure that you post a link back to this site with my recipe. Thank you.**



  1. Make brownies according to instructions on the package. Make them to fit the 9 X 13 pan.

  2. Line the litter box with parchment cooking paper. (I have read that the litter pan is not treated to hold food. Now I don't think that a one feast of this great cat litter cake would matter but to use over and over again, it's probably a good idea to line the litter box. We didn't line ours and no one got sick better to be safe than sorry. I don't want anyone to get sick.)

  3. After brownies are cooled, break into large chunks and place into cat litter pan.

  4. Spread frosting onto the brownies, making sure none of the brownies are exposed.

  5. Put some animal crackers or shortbread cookies in a baggie and smash into tiny bits.

    Using the flat side of a meat tenderizer works wonders (or hammer or anything else handy). You don't want to have a fine sand but a bit chunky (small chunky, see picture below).

  6. Take a small amount of crushed cookies and set aside in a small baggie.

  7. Make sure you have enough crushed cookies to cover the frosting. Spread the cookies on the frosting.

  8. Take the amount of cookies that you set aside and drip a few drops of green food coloring into the baggie. Seal and shake up. Try to color all the chunks in this baggie. Keep adding more food coloring until most of the chunks have some kind of green on them. Doesn't have to be perfect.

  9. Spread the green colored cookies in with the others.

    (If you have cats, you probably have a good idea where this is going. If you don't have cats, you want the green to be spread sparsely around. Try not to have big areas of just green. Not all cat litter is solid green but have green spread around.)

  10. Get a small saucer or microwave safe plate. Unwrap about a dozen (12) tootsie rolls. You will need more if you are using the miniature tootsie rolls. Place the unwrapped rolls on the plate and microwave for about 30 seconds on 50% power.

  11. Test the tootsie roll to see if it is soft enough to change the shape. If not, repeat above.

  12. Now pinch, twist, and bend your, um...., cat droppings (poopies) into the desired shapes.

  13. Place your newly shaped "poopies" onto the crushed cookies (litter). Make sure you have the infamous "poopie" caught on the side or hanging over the edge.

  14. Tuck the scoop into the cat litter cake and you got it!

First victim to take a bite out of your cat litter cake is scared out of their wits (or just totally grossed out.) But after that, it's a great cake! Enjoy!

Cat Litter Cake in all it's glory!


Return to top of Cat Litter Cake recipe

Subscribe to the Free Helpful Halloween Hints!

the Gentleman & the Coffin

Your Email

Your Name

Then click

I keep this private